About Winter Jewelry — Custom Diamond Engagement Rings in Williamsville & Buffalo, NY

Looking for a private jeweler who makes the engagement-ring process simple, personal, and transparent? Winter Jewelry is Western New York’s by-appointment destination for custom diamond engagement rings, wedding bands, and fine diamond jewelry—serving Williamsville, Buffalo, Amherst, Orchard Park, Niagara Falls, Wheatfield, Lewiston, and the surrounding Erie County area.

Our Story & Values

Winter Jewelry, founded in October of 1980 by Rick Winter, is celebrating a 45 year anniversary as a custom-design and manufacturer of fine jewelry. The company began strictly as a wholesale jeweler at Eastern Hills Mall providing repair work and customized finished jewelry to some of Western New York’s finest retail jewelers, including Zales, Jaccards, Sibley’s and Gordon Brothers. In 1983, Rick moved his operation to his home in North Tonawanda and began providing service directly to a retail clientele from his home office. Rick met customers there, by appointment only, for twenty years, where he designed and manufactured fine jewelry for people from throughout all of Western New York. The company’s focus then and now are diamond engagement rings and wedding bands.

In 2009, Rick’s son, Elliott Winter, became a full-time employee of the family business and has carried on the family tradition of providing attentive, personalized service for an ever-expanding jewelry clientele. Elliott manages the entire daily operation of Winter Jewelry now in our Williamsville office. In 2024, under Elliott’s leadership, Winter Jewelry was named the Buffalo News “Best of 716” in the retail jewelry category. Rick and Elliott cherish the relationships built and maintained throughout the WNY community and look forward to providing a quality fine jewelry experience to its customer base, both new and old.

What We Specialize In

Creating custom jewelry is a collaborative journey. Our transparent 4-step process ensures your vision is transformed into a wearable work of art that exceeds your expectations.

Custom diamond engagement rings (oval, round, radiant, pear, marquise, princess, solitaire, halo)

Wedding bands and anniversary bands

Diamond jewelry: studs, pendants, bracelets, and more

Natural & lab-grown diamonds with exceptional sparkle and value

Every piece is created with attention to detail and priced competitively—delivering luxury quality without the traditional retail markup.

Winter Jewelry shows off stylish rings and necklaces, giving ideas for unique looks with their custom pieces.

A Private, By-Appointment Experience

Jewelry Services: Repairs, Repurposing & Buying

From ring resizing and stone tightening to full restorations, our jewelry repair work keeps heirlooms beautiful and secure. Have pieces you no longer wear? We repurpose old jewelry into modern, everyday designs—or offer strong prices for old diamonds and gold.

Lab-Grown & Natural Diamonds — Your Choice

Whether you’re drawn to the tradition of natural diamonds or the innovation of lab-grown diamonds, we’ll help you compare beauty, value, and style to find the right fit for your story. (Ask us about shape options like oval, radiant, and pear.)

Areas We Serve

We work with clients across Buffalo, Williamsville, Orchard Park, Amherst, Niagara Falls, Wheatfield, Lewiston, and all of WNY. Prefer to browse first? Explore select pieces online, then book a visit to see them in person.

CALL US

General Inquiries
Phone: (716) 309 4276

TEXT US

General Inquiries
Phone: (716) 309 4276

ASSISTANCE HOURS

Monday: 10 am - 4:30 pm
Tuesday to Friday: 10 am - 7 pm Saturday: 11 am - 3pm
Sunday: Closed

MAIN STORE

5500 Main St #210 Williamsville, NY 14221

Ready to Design Your Ring?

Let’s craft something timeless. Book a private consultation to talk style, stones, and budget—and start building your custom engagement ring today.